Reading PJ's comments on his Mongolia experience (previous post) reminded of the situation in India.
In one of the tours we made in Ahmedabad, we visited an ancient step-well that's 6 storeys below ground level. It was a magnificent, awe-inspiring well design...i could sense how sacred water means to the Indians of that time, and perhaps even more so now...for while rainwater used to be stored up to the brim, especially in monsoon seasons, i was told that it hardly even reaches to the 3rd level from below in our era. Hell, when we visited, the water was at the "B6" level...which rendered it unusable. The fact that India did not have a proper monsoon (rainfalls were scarce) in the last 4 years compounded the water shortage crisis.
Reading a newspaper article a few days later that Ahmedabad is to build another 5-10 nos. of high class hotels (on top of existing 4) in anticipation of its growing tourist value distressed me further. Already, local ground water is being overpumped for hotel use across cities in india, so much so that the locals are granted access to water supply only TWICE a day - once each morning n evening - while tourists like us would have "endless" supply, to support our foreign daily routine: bathing twice a day, getting complimentary drinking water in our rooms, going for laundry service every other day...I was extremely disturbed...how would I feel if i don't have free access to resources in my own land, which foreigners get to enjoy unconditionally? Anger n resentment definitely; Instead, the locals always greeted us with warmth n welcome.
I'm not blaming the tourists per se; part of India IS hot n dirty...expecting foreigners to adapt immediately to the local way of life is like training your horse to be a camel. Moreover, tourism does create revenue for many cities, n tourists are there to relax, not "suffer"...
Sigh, I don't even know who to point fingers to actually...the government? the tourist industry? the natural humanistic behaviour?? The only possible way out of this dilemma is to create awareness amongst the tourists of the value of water in India, and show respect for it.
Still, shouldnt the scenes that lay out before them the minute they step out of the hotel already do that? Yet, i find it quite incredulous how many people's minds can just "switch on or off", looking without seeing, making no effort to reflect upon their consumption behaviour...
Sinful Paradise
In the oasis-like desert camp we stayed in Manvar, we even had modern bathroom facilities in EVERY tent, heated showers in the day. I had asked a staff where the water came from, in which he had assured me it came from a local well that villagers have free access to. When we visited the villagers the next day however, it's apparent they hadn't bathed for days...a child's finger wound was even caked in mud..
Back in the desert hotel, i could only gawk at the pristine swimming pool that's hardly used:
To be continued...
2 comments:
Namaste, I am glad to read that someone else questions the tourists' luxuries and at the same time realizes that the tourists are not there to suffer in the same way as the locals. But what I find really disturbing is the fact, that the massive middle class, (not to mention the rupee millionaires and billionaires) doesn't seem to be targeted by the government to either contribute in taxes, which could then be used to seal the roads at least and build schools and hospitals for the poor ones. And it is also amazing that the poor people only target tourists in a most annoying manner for alms and leave their local landlords alone and cow-tow even to them. I have been to hotels where the servants were not paid any wages, but depended on 'bakscheesh' for which they had to beg at the door. This was in Varanasi. The governor of Bihar had just been sacked and had vanished with all the state's funds; and the streets were in a horrendous condition with hold-ups by armed bandits, who demand a ransom. This was also on the way from Varanasi to Gaya/Bodh Gaya. There is no easy solution here. If we boycott the country, it will even be worse. But there's certainly no fun in seeing such dire poverty and suffering. Danuta
what is important is to know where the water comes from & what are the efforts done by the hotel to conserve water & also how it helps in conserving the local eco system -- its also important to know what is the positive impact of this hotel on the neighbouring area in terms of employment.
Setting up hotels in the miidle of nowhere is not an easy job -- I am sure a lot of effort has gone into this knowing the conditions in India
Post a Comment